My Letter of Apology to Ruben Amaro
Posted by Johnny Goodtimes on July 30th, 2010
Let me start by saying that you were right and I was wrong. You were smart and I was stupid. You were handsome and I was, quite frankly, looking like hell.
I had been furious at you since December. When you dealt Cliff Lee to the Mariners for three stiffs, I ripped you and the franchise a new one. And it didn’t stop there. Any time the Phils started slumping, or Lee started pitching well, or when quite frankly we were just in a pissy mood and wanted to displace some anger, BMT or I would tear you a new one, talk about how you had hosed the fans. Since you knew the games were going to sell out anyway, our story went, you could take advantage of our loyalty by dumping Cliff Lee off at the bargain bin and save yourself and ownership a few duckets.
Then, when the whole first half of the season was spent watching a punchless Phils team struggle, and watch Joe Blanton completely fall to pieces in a #3 spot that would have been Lee’s, our frustration and fury really reached a fever pitch. A mere two weeks ago, I said that it was time to write the season off. And that was BEFORE the disastrous Midwest road wing through Chicago and St. Louis.
But you did not give up. You did not throw in the towel. You went out and got a pitcher who, while may not be quite as good as Lee, is pretty damn close. Furthermore, while there was no chance that we were going to get Lee back after this year, we will get Oswalt back next year, guaranteed. In other words, we got one of the Top 12 pitchers in baseball for two pennant chases instead of one. And you got him for our #4 pitcher and bag of peanuts. There is nothing I can say besides brilliant. You showed all the signs of a good GM: you were patient, you were shrewd, and you capitalized on your previous relationships, in this case one with Ed Wade. The fact that you were somehow able to do all of this without needing to get rid of Jayson Werth is astounding.
I am still hearing people crying about Cliff Lee. Speaking as someone whose mancrush on Lee kept me despondent from the day he left until, oh, around 1 p.m. yesterday, I am here to say: Get over it. What’s done is done. The Phillies now have three of the best pitchers in baseball. Despite being completely snakebitten by injury, they are a mere 2.5 games out of first. Now is not the time to whine. I appreciate everything Lee did for this franchise, but do yourself a favor and take a look at Oswalt’s career numbers. They are better than Lee’s. And that’s our #3 pitcher, folks. If you can look at the Phils starting pitching rotation, and still find something to whine about, well then quite frankly you should just become a Rangers fan. As Norman Dale says in Hoosiers, “I would hope you would support who we are, not who we are not.”
Ruben, I fully support who we are, and I appreciate you busting your butt to get this deal done, the fact that you somehow keep Werth on the squad, and made us once again a top contender for the Series. All is forgiven, and I hope you can forgive us for busting your balls so hard these past few months. You are a genius, sir. An absolute genius. (Unless Oswalt pitches poorly tonight, in which case I can’t believe you were dumb enough to let Cliff Lee go.)
Yours truly,
Johnny Goodtimes
Posted in Phillies | 6 Comments »







